Trump points the way to universal health care!
In all the articles I’ve read about President Trump’s Covid-19 diagnosis and subsequent hospitalization, I have yet to see a single word about what I consider the biggest lesson of this whole affair: That Trump, unlike the great majority of US citizens, has access to unlimited health care, without having to worry about pesky things like bills and co-pays – let alone having to worry about facing a huge final bill that might be multiple times his annual income, as many people in the US who are without health insurance do today.
However,
I’m certainly not advocating that Trump be sent a hefty bill when his disease
has passed (and I honestly hope he doesn’t die from his illness, even though he’s
built a kind of cottage industry based on hinting that opponents like Hillary
Clinton and criminal suspects who haven’t been tried should be summarily dispatched
to meet their Maker, by whoever happens to have the opportunity and a gun to
accomplish the deed). I am suggesting that it’s more and more untenable
to argue that this level of health care is just “too expensive” to offer to every
US resident, when Trump is the one individual who has been most responsible for
the scale and deadliness of the current pandemic, and thus is just about the
least “deserving” of this level of treatment.
This
situation is made even more poignant by the fact that it is quite likely the Supreme Court – following the strong urging of the Trump administration – will
in early December strike down the ACA altogether (and whether or not Judge Amy
Coney Barrett is confirmed has nothing to do with this result. Even if she isn’t
confirmed by the time of this ruling, the current 5-3 conservative/liberal
split will turn into a 4-4 tie if Chief Justice Roberts votes to support the
ACA, which is likely. And the fact that the Supreme Court is deadlocked will leave in place the
lower court’s ruling, which was that the ACA should be struck down in its
entirety. A second conservative justice will have to join Roberts, again whether
or not Judge Barrett is confirmed, in order for the Court to actually uphold
the ACA). This will mean that at least 23 million additional people will be on track to lose their
health insurance, beyond the already unconscionable at least 30 million who
don’t have it today.
Will
this likely ruling turn into the disaster that it appears to be? Actually, I
think it would be a great opportunity, although only if the Democrats win both
the presidency (which I’ve long regarded as certain) and control of the Senate
(which I think is highly likely but not certain). I say this for two reasons. The
first is that if the Court ends the ACA, there will without doubt be a grace
period of at least one year - a stay of execution, if you will (and that phrase has a literal meaning in this case!).
The
second is that having the ACA struck down will give Democrats all the ammunition
they need to make providing truly universal health care their first order of
business when the new Congress opens in January. It doesn’t matter whether it’s
a single payer system like in Canada or the UK, or an insurance-based system like
in the Netherlands or Switzerland (although my preference is the latter). And in
designing the new system, Congress won’t be encumbered by having to accommodate
the current ACA structure, which was built with a lot of compromises that will
no longer be needed to get the bill passed (and if the GOP senators try to
filibuster the bill, well…I couldn’t think of a better justification for
killing the filibuster altogether than the fact that having the new bill go
down to defeat will result in 23 million Americans losing
their health insurance).
And to those who will inevitably argue that the US can’t afford universal health care, even though we’re the only major industrial country that doesn’t have it now, all the supporters have to do is point to President Trump. He deserved to have the best care available. The rest of the country deserves to have it as well.
I would love to hear any comments or questions you have
on this post. Drop me an email at tom@tomalrich.com
Comments
Post a Comment